PDA

View Full Version : Men Suddenly In Black (Hong Kong)


bruce-leroy
06-02-2004, 14:01
Men Suddenly in Black (http://global.yesasia.com/assocred.asp?LU83C65N+http://global.yesasia.com/en/PrdDept.aspx/pid-1002885870/did-0/code-c/section-videos/)


Infidelity has always been a popular theme for comedy, and it has rarely been deployed more effectively than in this utterly fantastic, and frequently hilarious, tale of four guys and their quest to cheat on their other halves. When their partners take a trip to Thailand, Tin and his friends take a vow to taste fourteen hours of freedom and rejoice in commiting ultimate acts of betrayal. Unfortunately for them, the women suddenly become savvy to their dastardly plans. What follows is a series of (mis)adventures, as the guys try earnestly to succeed in their mission, while their ladies close in....

Eric Tsang has come a long way since playing the butt of everyone's jokes in the Lucky Stars movies. Here, he is on fine comic form, with able support from Jordan Chan and Chapman To (in his least irrating performance so far). As the women scorned, relative veterans Teresa Mo and Candy Lo steal the acting honours from their younger (and some might say) prettier proteges - Marsha Yuen and Tiffany Lee.

One of the main sources of enjoyment is the way in which classic action movie scenarios are parodied. For example, one set piece involves our four (anti?) heroes escaping from a brothel, being chased by ruthless paparazzi (who have been tipped off by their wives that said brothel may have underage girls). The difference being that the sequence is shot like a John Woo movie, with the paparazzi closing in like proffesional hitmen, and instead of guns, the guys use water hoses and cameras to fend them off. You really have to see it yourself to understand what I am trying to convey. I haven't seen anything like it for a while.

Throw in a host of great star cameos, the best being Tony Leung Kar Fei as a serial philanderer known as Uncle Kau - the Don Vito Corleone of philanderers such is the level of respect and worship bestowed to him by the guys - makes Men Suddenly in Black one of the most refreshing and intelligently executed comedies I have seen in quite some time (and not just restricted to Hong Kong). On this evidence, writer/director Edmond Pang is certainly one of the best emerging talents from Hong Kong in the 21st century. Time to watch You Shoot I Shoot.

4/5



DVD

I have the Mei Ah R0 2 disc release, and it maintains the high standard of recent Mei Ah dvds. AV is very good with anamorphic picture and a vibrant Dolby Digital 5.1 track. I watched the movie with the Cantonese track, but it is also available in Mandarin. English subs are very good quality. A big bonus is the the audio commentary featuring director, producer, cinematographer (I think - it could be the editor) also comes with English subtitles!

Disc 2 has extras including making of, deleted scenes, outtakes, and storyboard comparisons. I haven't watched disc 2 yet.

The 2 disc set is under £6 (exc. postage) at yesasia and I would definitely recommend throwing it in with your next order if you are after something different, and fed up with all the rubbish to come out of HK in recent years.

wong fei hong
06-02-2004, 14:33
I agree, this is really different and a great deal of fun. Eric Tsang, Jordan Chan and Big Tony Leung are brilliant, and the whole thing is a pointer for the way forward for HK cinema, playing to the strengths of the industry.

I didn't know there were commentary subs! I'll be going back to this disc very soon...

new forms
06-02-2004, 20:02
nice review bruce,

on my last multiple order the last film was a toss up between ordering this and Lost In Time, went for LIT due to the reviews in this forum but will look to pick up MSIB on my next order,

Eric Tsang cant seem to do much wrong at the moment, whether its comedy action or melodrama its seems as if he can master it all,

and after seeing colour of the truth i think jordan chan can do good things,

and as for the ever present chapman to, after seeing the extra's on infernel affiars 2 it seems as if there's a serious artiste just busting to get out :eek:

if i'd known this comes with a subbed com track and was so cheap would have ordred a lot sooner

bruce-leroy
07-02-2004, 01:05
Thanks.

Eric Tsang has developed wonderfully as an actor. His performances in the likes of Infernal Affairs and Comrades are testament to that. He has come on so much since the 80s.

SheepDip
07-02-2004, 16:48
It's not getting a very good write-up with the comments on Yesasia (But you do get a lot of butt-heads putting comments on there who know squat!).

Still I might just get this one along with my next Yesasia order.

bruce-leroy
08-02-2004, 02:30
I hardly ever read or pay attention any of the customer feedback on yesasia. 8/10 they seem only to be interested in who stars in the film, rather than the actual film itself. A bit fanboyish at times.

Cirrus888
08-02-2004, 06:09
Great write up and it escaped my attention that this was done by the director who did I shoot You shoot (still unavailable on DVD!) the reviews for men in black have been good but the reviews for I shoot You Shoot were even better ... I will will get this as my first intro to the director's work.

Jimmyboy
09-02-2004, 00:25
Originally posted by bruce-leroy
I would definitely recommend throwing it in with your next order if you are after something different, and fed up with all the rubbish to come out of HK in recent years.

Bit harsh there don't yer think Brucey ?.
What With Men Suddenly in Black, Lost in Time, Naked Ambition, Running on Karma, Warriors of Heaven and Earth, not to mention the Infernal Affairs Trilogy, I think there's been a fairly decent out put from Hong Kong recently.

I can't say I could real off 8 decent American movies off the top of my head from the last 24 months.

Shingster
09-02-2004, 00:40
Naked Ambition isn't anything special at all and Warriors of Heaven and Earth isn't a HK film.

American Splendour, Lost in Translation, Two Towers, Return of the King, Intolerable Cruelty, Mystic River, Finding Nemo, Pirates of the Caribbean, Kill Bill, Big Fish, Dogville, Open range, last Samurai, Elephant, 21 grams, Master and Commander, Once Upon a Time in Mexico, Shangai knights, Cold Mountain.

Game set and match USA.

Jimmyboy
09-02-2004, 00:59
They're some seriously crap files in your list - Cold Mountain!. :o
I can't say I've ever had much of an urge to watch a bunch of midgets run across a field for 3 hours at a time so that pretty much rules out the LOTR's movies.

I was gonna draw a line between Warriors of Heaven and Earth with the rest of the list but I honestly didn't think anyone would be that petty as to pick me up on it. :p


My point still remains, I don't think it's totally fair to say HK films have been rubbish over recent years. If anything, I'm quite optimistic.


Oh - I forgot PTU from my original list.

bruce-leroy
09-02-2004, 13:55
Originally posted by Jimmyboy
Bit harsh there don't yer think Brucey ?.
What With Men Suddenly in Black, Lost in Time, Naked Ambition, Running on Karma, Warriors of Heaven and Earth, not to mention the Infernal Affairs Trilogy, I think there's been a fairly decent out put from Hong Kong recently.



Maybe a little bit OTT. ;) But I was referring to crap (IMO) like Twins Effect. Actually, I agree that the last couple of years has seen a bit of a resurgence in better quality HK movies. Didn't think that much of PTU myself.

Ono
09-02-2004, 18:57
Ahh, sod it. Only £6 so I'll use it as a makeweight on my YA order. :D

Jimmyboy
09-02-2004, 22:47
Originally posted by bruce-leroy
Maybe a little bit OTT. ;) But I was referring to crap (IMO) like Twins Effect. Actually, I agree that the last couple of years has seen a bit of a resurgence in better quality HK movies. Didn't think that much of PTU myself.

Yeah I know what you mean about junk like Twins Effect. The surgence of pop culture films which star a who's nobody of the canto pop scene are generally best avoided tbh.:gag:

Jimmyboy
10-03-2004, 23:24
Watched this tonight and it's everything Bruce said it was.
Highly entertaining if morally questionable.


Feminists would have a field day with this one....:nono:

bruce-leroy
10-03-2004, 23:26
I don't it's meant to be taken seriously though Jim. ;) It's nice to have a film so un-PC for once anyway. :p

68monkey
11-03-2004, 03:26
Originally posted by Jimmyboy
Watched this tonight and it's everything Bruce said it was.
Highly entertaining if morally questionable.

Feminists would have a field day with this one....:nono:
Well, I think Bruce is right in saying it's not really meant to be taken seriously, but if you want a feminist's opinion on the movie anyway. . . . ;)

MSIB is average. The comedy is clever, but there's nothing really outstandingly original here. Yes, the parodies of HK films are fun, and Eric Tsang just re-performs a lot of his IA scenes with a comic twist, but a lot of it just goes on a bit too long. (The John Woo shootout parody in the back alley, for instance. Funny for a minute, but too drawn out). The movie definitely has its moments (thinking Jordan Chan, cigarette, and suitcase), but overall, I wouldn't rate this as a classic. It's more like a 10-minute joke drawn out to a full-length film.

(And yes, the ending bugged me a little ;) )

Originally posted by new forms
and as for the ever present chapman to, after seeing the extra's on infernel affiars 2 it seems as if there's a serious artiste just busting to get out :eek:
Hehe, well it looked to me as if he might have added something in his boxer briefs to give him the appearance of having more to "bust out" :p Sorry, but still not sexy, Chapman To. :oh-hum:

Jimmyboy
11-03-2004, 15:43
I agree about the ending.

This was one of the few HK films where I thought the usual melodramatic closure I've come to expect was actually needed.

Cirrus888
24-12-2005, 20:00
Just seen this and I personally think its better than both I shoot you shoot which has a weaker latter half and the generally average but interspersed with funny moments AV.

Outrageously funny throughout and one of the smartest and funniest HK films I've seen in a long time.

Alan b
24-12-2005, 20:03
Moving to World Cinema and DVD Forum

Ricochan38
24-12-2005, 20:58
Eric Tsang was good in golden chicken also, he is a good actor.

new forms
26-12-2005, 12:10
Tsang can do it all,

he's one of the most skilled, versatile and charismatic actors out there on the world scene